I’ve only found a couple people, other than myself, that don’t like
Elf. Everyone else seems to think it’s a new Christmas classic – and that doesn’t really sit well with me. I went into
Elf hoping I would like it, but I came away feeling the movie is… well, the only word I can come up with is “soulless.”
Buddy the Elf spends the entire movie trying to spread Christmas cheer. Of course, since he’s played by Will Ferrell, he does it by being as obnoxious as possible. Which… you know, it’s actually fine. Will Ferrell’s just not my favorite actor, but I understand other people like him. I don’t get his appeal, but I’m pretty sure there are people out there who don’t grasp why I willingly spent money on the complete
Powerpuff Girls cartoon series on DVD.
The problem I have, though, is with the show’s definition of “Christmas cheer.” Meaning, I have no clue why they think Christmas cheer is important.
Maybe “Christmas cheer” is just a euphemism for Buddy the Elf’s eternal optimism. I guess that makes a little bit of sense. Unfortunately, Buddy’s “optimism” alienates him from everyone else in the movie. He only makes friends in the mailroom because he gets them all drunk. He gets in a fight with the midget in the boardroom because he’s completely clueless. The other elves don’t like him. Even his father throws him out, and brings him back in to the family mostly out of guilt.
Above: COMEDY!!!
(You can make a case that he wins over Zooey Deschanel… except there’s nothing about that relationship that strikes me as even being remotely believable. I don’t even think Ms. Deschanel buys that contrived romance – she looks completely annoyed at Will Ferrell every time they’re on screen together.)
I believe a good Christmas story is one that shows how the season can positively change a life – not because it’s a magical time of year, but because it’s a time of year when people are encouraged to do good. More than that, though, the great Christmas classics work because they are HONEST.
Take a look at
It’s a Wonderful Life. Here we have a realistic depiction of one man’s life, his trials and faults, and the great impact he can have on those around him. There’s no scenery-chewing, no cheap laughs or forced sentimentality. We cheer for Jimmie Stewart because he’s a good man, and, at Christmastime, he is rewarded for his decency.
How about
A Charlie Brown Christmas? That movie’s all about honesty. Again, there’s no forced laughter (I dare say it’s one of the un-funniest things the Peanuts have done outside of shilling insurance). Still, even I get a little choked up when Charlie Brown, in frustration, screams out his frustration about not understanding Christmas, and Linus, very simply, replies by reciting the story of the angels announcing Christ’s birth from Luke 2. And do you remember what happens next? The children decide to stop harassing Charlie Brown and decorate his little Christmas tree. The reason for the holiday prompts, not just a hollow “belief,” but a real, concrete, kind action.
Even
A Christmas Story, which doesn’t really carry any of those “heartwarming messages” about loving your fellow man or whatever, succeeds as a Christmas movie because it honestly portrays how the Christmas season brings a family together, after all their fights over furnaces and lamps and Red Rider BB Guns, around the table at a Chinese restaurant in a spirit of love. Unconventional, perhaps, but completely honest.
Okay, back to
Elf. Remember that climactic moment when New Yorkers get together to sing the Christmas carols that fuel Santa’s magic sleigh. I get to that point of the movie, and I ask myself, “Is that what the movie calls ‘Christmas cheer’? Believe in Santa Claus and you’ll have a happy Christmas?”
No, that can’t be the moral. I’m twenty-six years old now, and I’ve long since learned – we’ll say about six years ago – that there’s no such thing.
Besides, Santa Claus has become a symbol of the commercial side of Christmas that most people have come to detest over the years. “Ho ho ho!” he says. “Buy Coca-Cola or I’m putting you on the naughty list!”
Above: Sellout!!!
I think we’ve done the man a huge disservice. True, Santa Claus isn’t REAL in the sense that he’s up at the North Pole spying on everyone and overseeing the construction of countless X-Boxes and DVD gift sets, but he represents something fundamentally decent about humankind – the potential we have to put others above ourselves to the benefit of everyone involved.
A week or two ago, I saw a friend post on Facebook that her daughter came home from school one day upset. Someone had told her that Santa Claus wasn’t real. My friend said she was planning on breaking that news to her daughter by having her daughter get presents for someone else – by
being “Santa Claus.” I love that idea so much that I want to have a kid RIGHT NOW so I can do that with my children.
Anyone have any kids they aren’t using?
I’m not a huge fan of those Rankin-Bass shorts about Santa Claus, like
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer and
Santa Claus is Comin’ to Town. Still, I understand they deserve their place in the canon of Christmas classics because they encourage people, not just to believe in the jolly old elf that does so much good, but to emulate him.
So, yeah… In my mind,
Elf fails as a Christmas movie. I won’t fault you for liking the movie, if you want to. Maybe your idea of Christmas spirit actually is watching a man-child in green tights eat enough sugar to put the Stay Puff Marshmallow Man into a coma. Just know that, by my above reasoning, you’re completely wrong.
Of course, you can just dismiss my opinion because I’ve spent WAY too much time thinking about a movie that you’re just meant to sit back and laugh at… which, by the way, you’d probably be right to do.